1968    
   Absence of a Cello
   The Glass Menagerie
   You Can't Take it With You

1969    
   The Odd Couple
   And Then There Were None

   Our Town
   Lil' Abner

1970    
   Cactus Flower
   Born Yesterday
   Once Upon a Mattress

1971    
   Plaza Suite
   Bus Stop
   Little Mary Sunshine

1972    
   Butterflies Are Free
   Everybody Loves Opal
   Carnival

1973    
   Love Rides The Rails, Or Will The Main Train Run Tonight?
   Mary Mary
   Finian's Rainbow

1974    
   The Roar of the Greasepaint, The Smell of the Crowd
   The Boyfriend
   The Last of Mrs. Lincoln

1975    
   The Cat and the Canary
   Annie Get Your Gun
   The Private Ear, The Public Eye
   Little Women
   She Loves Me
   Harvey

1976    
   The Sound of Music
   Picnic
   The Pajama Game
   Blithe Spirit
   Barefoot In The Park
   Finishing Touches
   The Skin of Our Teeth
   The Fantasticks
   A Christmas Carol

1977    
   Babes in Arms
   The Star-Spangled Girl
   Death of a Salesman
   Fiddler On The Roof
   Grease
   A Thousand Clowns
   The Music Man
   You're A Good Man Charlie Brown
   Toys in the Attic
   Life With Father
   A Christmas Carol

1978    
   HMS Pinafore
   Inherit The Wind
   South Pacific
   Carousel
   Count Dracula
   No, No, A Million Times No!
   Story Theater
   Appleseed Man
   The Subject Was Rose
   Here's Love

1979    
   Hansel & Gretel
   The Mikado
   Hello, Dolly
   Once Upon a Mattress
   A Streetcar Named Desire
   You Can't Take it With You
   How To Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
   How The Grinch Stole Christmas
   Dirty Work at the Crossroads
   Sweet Charity
   Same Time, Next Year
   South Pacific
   Wait Until Dark
   Babes in Toyland

1980    
   Broadway Revue
   The Shadow Box
   Lorelei
   Come, Blow Your Horn
   Charlie's Aunt
   Bye Bye Birdie
   Dial "M" for Murder
   A Christmas Carol

1981    
   The Pirates of Penzance
   Witness For the Prosecution
   The Miracle Worker
   The Odd Couple
   Oklahoma!
   The Philadelphia Story
   Oliver!
   I Do, I Do
   Holiday on Broadway

1982    
   Iolanthe
   The Price
   The Belle of Amherst
   Godspell
   How The Other Half Loves
   Dylan
   Guys and Dolls
   I Do, I Do
   The Sold Gold Cadillac

1983    
   Patience
   The Lion in Winter
   The Miser
   Impromptu
   Damn Yankees
   Funny Girl
   Sorry, Wrong Number
   Deathtrap
   Mixed Couples
   Dames at Sea
   The Matchmaker
   Holiday on Broadway

1984    
   The Gondoliers
   Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
   The Hasty Heart
   The King and I
   The Man in The Dog Suit
   A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
   Come Back, Little Sheba
   Room Service
   A Christmas at Juniper Tavern

   A Christmas Carol

1985    

   Annie
   The Yeoman of the Guard
   That Championship Season
   The King and I
   On Golden Pond
   Something's Afoot
   George Washington Slept Here
   The Best Christmas Pageant Ever
   The Sunshine Boys
   Twelve Angry Men

1986    
   Ruddigore
   Absurd Person Singular
   The Women
   Any Wednesday
   Fiddler On The Roof
   The Glass Menagerie
   California Suite
   The Emperor's New Clothes
   Grease
   The Gift of the Magi
   The Best Christmas Pageant Ever

1987    
   Hurray For Hollywood
   A Midsummer Nights Dream
   Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?
   Jesus Christ Superstar
   Finian's Rainbow
   God's Favorite

   Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat

1988    
   HMS Pinafore
   Cabaret
   Agnes of God
   The Foreigner
   Quilters
   Catch Me if You Can
   South Pacific
   The Littlest Angel

1989    
   Painting Churches
   The Mikado
   The Nerd
   The Man of La Mancha
   The Man in the Red Underwear
   The Tempest
   Morning's at Seven
   Oklahoma!
   As You Like It

1990    
   The Pirates of Penzance
   Trying Angels
   Little Mary Sunshine
   The Dark at the Top of the Stairs
   Seven Keys to Baldpate
   Love, Sex, and the IRS
   Bell, Book and Candle
   Cinderella: A British Pantomime
   A Christmas Revue
   A Christmas Carol

1991    
   Steel Magnolias
   My Fair Lady
   Brighton Beach Memoirs
   Deadwood Dick
   Little Shop of Horrors
   Peter and The Wolf
   Strike Up the Band
   A Christmas Revue

1992    
   You're A Good Man Charlie Brown
   Strange Snow
   Bits of Broadway
   Taming of the Shrew
   Broadway Bound
   Frankenstein
   A Christmas Carol

1993    
   The Importance of Being Earnest
   Talking With
   The Music Man
   Driving Miss Daisy
   A Broadway Revue
   A Streetcar Named Desire
   Pirates of Penzance
   The Fantasticks

1994    
   The Mousetrap
   Godspell
   Noises Off
   The 1940s Radio Hour
   Romeo & Juliet
   Crossing Delancey
   The Shadow Box

1995    
   Greater Tuna
   Dames at Sea
   The Night of the Iguana
   Nunsense
   Isn't It Romantic
   A Flea in Her Ear
   A Doll's House
   Oliver!

1996    
   The Winter's Tale
   Nunsense
   Crimes of the Heart
   Trial By Jury and A Gilbert & Sulivan Gala
   Lend Me a Tenor
   Hallelujah Hopscotch
   Broadway Then & Now
   A Walk in the Woods
   Silent Night

1997    
   Gilligan's Island
   Guys & Dolls
   Keely and Du
   Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
   Our Town
   Last of the Red Hot Lovers
   Dracula
   I Hate Hamlet
   Annie

1998    
   The Real Inspector Hound
   Laughter on the 23rd Floor
   Singing In The Rain
   Damn Yankees
   On The Verge
   Twelfth Night
   Grace and Glorie
   Holiday on Broadway

1999    
   The Boys Next Door
   To Kill a Mockingbird
   Black Comedy
   The Wizard of Oz
   Fortinbras
   The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940
   Peter Pan

2000    
   Moon Over Buffalo
   Grease
   The Diary of Anne Frank
   Gypsy
   Sylvia
   Narnia
   The Sound of Music
   Arsenic and Old Lace
   It's a Wonderful Life

2001    
   The Miracle Worker
   Rumors
   The Dining Room
   The Wizard of Oz
   Biloxi Brides
   The Zoo Story
   West Side Story
   A Dickens Christmas Carol
   Beauty and the Beast

2002    
   Waiting in the Wings
   HMS Pinafore
   You Can't Take it With You
   Annie Get Your Gun
   The Ghost of Babe Ruth
   Kiss Me Kate
   Picnic
   Anne of Green Gables

2003    
   One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
   42nd Street
   Critic's Choice
   Seven Brides for Seven Brothers
   James and the Giant Peach
   King Lear
   The Legend of Sleepy Hollow
   Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella

2004    
   The Rainmaker
   Alice in Wonderland
   You're a Good Man Charlie Brown
   Footloose
   Anne of Avonlea
   The Octette Bridge Club
   The Music Man

2005    
   Mars/ Venus One Acts
   The Adventures of Tom Sawyer
   A Few Good Men
   The Student Prince
   Blithe Spirit
   Cabaret
   Dinner With Friends
   Run For Your Wife

2006    
   Claptrap
   Man of La Mancha
   Art
   Cheaper By The Dozen
   Glengarry Glenn Ross
   The Seven Year Itch
   Sweeney Todd
   Steel Magnolias
   Seussical The Musical

2007    
   Greater Tuna
   Fiddler on The Roof
   The Foreigner
   The Merry Widow
   The Laramie Project
   Pollyanna
   Deathtrap
   Scrooge

2008    
   Proof
   Nunsense
   Sordid Lives
   High School Musical
   Inherit The Wind
   Chicago
   Peter Pan The Musical

2009    
   Wings
   A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
   The Complete Works of William Shakespeare: Abridged
   Little Women
   Taffeta Memories
   Oliver
   Angel Street
   The Sound of Music

2010    
   The Fantasticks
   Rabbit Hole
   Carousel
   Not Waving
   Willy Wonka
   Over The River and Through The Woods
   Annie

2011    
   Don't Dress For Dinner
   The Tempest
   Arsenic and Old Lace
   Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
   Humble Boy
   Into The Woods
   The Nerd
   Narnia

2012    
   A Dicken's Christmas Carol
   The Rocky Horror Show
   On Golden Pond
   Suessical
   The Will Rogers Follies
   Lie, Cheat, and Genuflect
   The Best Christmas Pageant Ever

2013    
   The 39 Steps
   Quilters
   Much Ado About Nothing
   Little Shop of Horrors
   Born Yesterday
   Meet Me In St. Louis
   The Wiz

2014    
   Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
   Honk!
   I Love You Because
   The Secret Garden
   You Can't Take it With You
   Miracle on 34th Street

2015    
   Sylvia
   The Mystery of Edwin Drood
   The Diary of Anne Frank
   Oklahoma!
   Rumors
   White Christmas

2016    
   Driving Miss Daisy
   The Music Man
   Enchanted April
   The Producers
   Wait Until Dark
   A Christmas Story

2017    
   Calendar Girls
   Reefer Madness: The Musical
   The Gin Game
   To Kill a Mockingbird
   Stop Kiss
   Shrek: The Musical

2018    
   The Glass Menagerie
   The Wizard of Oz
   Sordid Lives
   Footloose
   The God Game
   It's a Wonderful Life

2019    
   It's Only a Play
   The Addams Family
   Peter and the Starcatcher
   The Graduate
   Swimming in the Shallows
   Disney's Newsies
   Disney's Beauty and the Beast

2020    
   Noises Off

2021    
   Novecento
   Tea For Three
   Talking With
   Love Letters
   All Together Now!
   A Christmas to Remember

2022    
   My Way
   Proof
   The Sound of Music
   Barefoot in the Park
   Mamma Mia!
   And Then There Were None
   A Christmas Carol

2023    
   Into The Woods
   Harvey
   9 to 5
   Pride & Prejudice
   Matilda: The Musical
   Puffs
   Anne of Green Gables